Ahhh I see what you mean. That's true Shirley and Howard Mollison don't have many redeemable traits or moments, but I agree with you that it was probably done on purpose. Although I suppose if I really wanted to think about it I could find them a redeemable trait or two...but they certainly not my favourite characters. Still I'm glad that you enjoyed the book! It surprised me that I enjoyed something that was gritty.

Martine//Ravenclaw