I'm not sure Slughorn would've KEPT Tonks, though, just based on her ability. While he probably would've snatched her up at the beginning, when he found out about her, her clumsiness might have been enough to make him stop giving her invitations. I do agree, though, that she SHOULD have been in the club, because she's such a BAMF.

Percy, of course, would be a PERFECT Slug Club member! Slughorn really likes being buttered up, and Percy LOVES buttering powerful people up, so they're a match made in heaven. I think they would've become BFFs had Percy still been in school when Slughorn started teaching again.

Adrienne//Gryffindor