You bring up good points, and with something like the Potions Club I would have an issue with it too. I think the reason it doesn't bug me too much for Slug Club is because I see it as a social club with little real value. The people, like Hermione and Harry, who don't go out of their way to use those connections will get nothing out of it. But since some of them, like the pro Quidditch player (whats-her-name?), obviously do, then your argument's definitely valid. I just hadn't thought of it that way, since I would've had no desire to be in it IRL.

Kimberly//Ravenclaw